Downtown Fort Wayne is hustling and bustling these days. Especially on a summer Friday night when the TinCaps are playing. It was a good thing we made reservations for Wine Down Tastings and Tapas, Fort Wayne’s newest small plates joint, located in The Harrison on Jefferson. After navigating the surrounding blocks, Beth finally secured a parking spot. As she made her way to the restaurant, Wendy was texting her. “Drama,” said Wendy. We’ll get back to that.
Beth finally arrived and joined Wendy at a table near the bar. The interior is lovely — a rich mix of wood and stone. One of the walls is completely lined with glass cases of wine bottles.
“So, what’s the drama?” Beth asked.
Wendy explained that multiple servers stopped by to introduce themselves and then proceeded to argue about who would get our table. We were seated right next to the servers station — an unfortunate spot. We were witness to several conversations that we would have preferred to miss.
When the victor of Server Battles arrived she handed us our “cards” for the self-serve wine bar. They are basically used as a tab to track your purchases throughout the evening. You pour the amount of wine you desire and can choose from three sizes, from a 1-ounce tasting pour to a full glass.
So, here it is. Confession time. Neither Beth or Wendy are big wine drinkers (duh, we like FOOD – it’s in the name!). In truth, the wine tasting option was wasted on us. It would be fun for people who like wine (but a wine drinking friend said they had too many sweet wines and not enough to her liking). We were sitting in a high traffic area, and if it were hopping in there, it’s easy see how the back & forth to the wine bar area would maybe make it miserable for tables in the vicinity. Regardless, they seem to have a wide variety of options.
We did however order drinks – in addition to the wine they have a large craft cocktail menu. They were running a special on Tequila, so Beth ordered a Margarita and Wendy ordered a Hibiscus Gin Sour.
As you may remember from our Salud visit, we are fans of Tapas. We ordered three plates — Pulled Pork Wontons ($9, 4 pieces), Crabmeat Stuffed Deviled Eggs ($9, 4 pieces) and BBQ Bison Meatballs ($9, 4 pieces). The Wontons arrived first and were brought by our original server. Several minutes later, the Stuffed Deviled Eggs appeared, brought by a chef. A different server brought the BBQ Bison Meatballs soon after. There didn’t seem to be any rhyme or reason to what they brought when – it was fine that the food didn’t all come at the same time, but it seemed a bit haphazard and random.
Beth: I feel somewhat remiss in that I cannot comment on the wine, which is of course their premiere offering. However, I have no problem chatting about the food, which I found lackluster. The wontons lacked flavor and the eggs lacked ample crabmeat. BBQ Bison Meatballs were quite tasty. The Margarita was, well, a Margarita. It was fine. Again, perhaps this is not their strong suit. It wasn’t bad, just not great.
Wendy: I would agree with everything Beth said. There was nothing wrong with the food, but there was nothing exciting about it either. The menu was far more interesting than the execution. The wontons reminded me of Chinese tacos – somewhat dry pulled pork in a wonton shell, with a lot of cilantro on top – but the assembly made it difficult to get everything in one bite, and once I got a mouthful of nothing but cilantro. Not my favorite. I had been very excited to come here ever since getting a glimpse of the menu offerings in a newspaper article months ago, but it did not live up to my expectations. I ate a light lunch that day so I would be really hungry for dinner, and what I’m about to say is about the worst thing I think I could say to a restaurant: I was still hungry when we left, but I didn’t want to eat more of their food to address that. I figured I could just go home and have a bowl of cereal instead.
Another oddity was the check. There was none. Everything was done on a handheld tablet type of things and when all was said and done we were given a totaled receipt. It would have been nice to be able to review the itemized bill.
The consensus here was that Wine Down showed great promise, but in many areas didn’t quite deliver. And if you go on a Summer game night, be sure to allow ample time to find a parking space – we would never, never, suggest that Fort Wayne has traffic or parking problems and we are both able bodied and have no problem walking, but neither of us accounted for the congestion of a baseball game and we were both late for our reservation time.
The Verdict
Beth: “Frankly my dear, I don’t give a damn.” I am always happy for additions to the Fort Wayne dining scene, and Wine Down will have a following among those eager for variety in wines. I hope that they pour the same attention into their food offerings.
Wendy: “Frankly my dear, I don’t give a damn.” Meh. I would go back if someone else wanted to, but I’m not likely to suggest it.
Wine Down Tasting & Tapas
301 W Jefferson Blvd
Suite 100
Fort Wayne, IN 46802
260-755-1019